“Are You Calvinist Or Arminian?” … Interpretations and Denominationalism Dividing Christians

Interpretations and denominationalism, rather than the belief in the core tenets of the Christian salvation, are now used by some Christians to determine salvation in Christ. The thief on the cross who accepted Jesus had no denominational leanings. He just believed Jesus and that earned him salvation.

On many occasions I have been asked, “Are you Calvinist or Arminian?” People don’t ask me if I believe in the triune God, (God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit).

They don’t ask me if I believe Jesus is God, (John 10:30; Colossians 2:9; Hebrews 1:3), and if I believe that Jesus is the Savior, and the only way to God, (John 14:6). They don’t ask me whether a person can or cannot be saved and become a child of God if that person does not believe that Jesus is God and the Savior. They don’t ask me if I believe and practice the Apostles’ doctrine, (Acts 2:42; Matthew 28:19-20).

Rather they are concerned whether I believe in Arminianism, Calvinism, or other denominational doctrines.

These doctrines that have torn Christians apart were not promulgated by Jesus nor by the Apostles. Jesus did not say they are the basis of our salvation. Calvinism and Arminianism, for example, were formulated by people in the 16th and the 17th centuries.

My response is always that I believe in the triune God (i.e., the trinity: God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit). I believe that God is One divine Essence in the Godhead. I believe the teachings that Jesus and the Apostles disseminated. I believe that Jesus is God, Jesus died for me and resurrected on the third day and will judge the living and the dead.

Denominational doctrines do not define our salvation, yet if you take one side the other will alienate you. This is unfortunate.

Interpretations of Biblical words, statements or contexts have torn Christians apart. Even though the interpretations do not define our salvation. Some Christians will have nothing to do with fellow Christians who disagree with their denominational doctrines. I have been sidelined before by some Christians because I did not share their beliefs. Some even decided to alienate me because of my views.

Yet these disagreements have nothing to do with our salvation.

The Apostle Paul addressed some problems at their time in Colossians 2:8-23, Romans 14:4-6, and Galatians 3:1-6.

The Bible is clear as to what makes us Christians or how we become Christians (passages include Matthew 28:19; Mark 16:16-20; John 3:16; John 15:4-16; Acts 2:38).  How we interpret or misinterpret some words of the Bible does not define our Christianity, unless our doctrines and practices disagree with the basic pillars or the core tenets of Christianity.

The true Christian must believe in the triune God (the Trinity – God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit). The true Christian believes that God is one Divine Essence (substance) in three persons, not three Gods (deities). The person of the Father, the person of the Son, and the person of the Holy Spirit are separate. But the Godhead of the Father, the Godhead of the Son, and the Godhead of the Holy Spirit is ONE, (Colossians 2:9). The Godhead is one in essence and Jesus is the only Lord and Savior of the world. God speaks through His Son, who is the express image of God’s person, (Hebrews 1:1-3).

These were tenets Jesus Christ taught the Apostles and commanded the Apostles to disseminate throughout the world, (Matthew 28:18-20; Luke 24:44-51; Acts 1:8; John 10:30 – God and Jesus are one in essence or substance).

Most of the doctrines that have become the pillars of various denominations were formulated many years after the core tenets of Christianity had been laid out in the Bible. The founders of these new doctrines interpreted the passages of the Bible according to their own personal understanding of what they read.

As I said earlier, the thief on the cross who accepted Jesus had no denominational learnings. He just believed in Jesus and that earned him salvation. We must, therefore, not alienate fellow Christians who do not share our denominational beliefs. We must not alienate a person who believes in the core tenets of Christianity, in the Lordship of Jesus, in the triune God, and what Jesus and the Apostles taught.

Mostly, we use biased lenses to see and interpret what we read. And so, we give our own interpretations and views and alienate other Christians who do not belong to our denominations, or who do not share our interpretations and views. Even within the denominations we encounter differences of interpretations and doctrines. Many denominations have split further because of further disagreements in interpretations within them as they refuse to consider each other’s views.

Even leading theologians have their biases. Martin Luther, for instance, expressed personal opinions and doubts about the authority of Hebrews, James, Jude, and Revelation. He called the Epistle of James “an epistle of straw.” He said its teaching on good works conflicted with his personal theology of justification by faith alone. Martin Luther did not ask the Holy Spirit to explain to him why the Holy Spirit inspired James to write on faith and works in the manner he did.

The early church believed that the books, (including the epistle of James), were authentic and inspired by the Holy Spirit. Our inability to understand some words or passages in the Bible, therefore, does not diminish the genuineness of such words or passages. Martin Luther, by his statement, implied that the Holy Spirit inspired James to write ‘an epistle of straw’. (Or he believed that James was not inspired to write that epistle.)  Despite that, Christians still hold Martin Luther in high esteem. Yet these same Christians will alienate fellow Christians who do not agree with what they believe.

But as I indicated, the words and beliefs we fight about do not define our salvation. Our salvation depends on the belief that Jesus is the only Lord and Savior, He died and resurrected, and that Jesus is God. True Christians believe in the triune God (God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit), and that God is One divine Essence in the Godhead. True Christians believe and practice the Apostles doctrine, (Acts 2:42; Matthew 28:18-20).

I believe that the words and the statements the writers and prophets used in the Bible are the words and statements that God (the Holy Spirit) intended. God speaks to us in the simple language that we can understand Him. He does not use obscure language.

Unfortunately, Satan has succeeded in tearing us apart by using insignificant doctrines. The doctrines we argue on and fight each other against do not determine our salvation. Yet Satan has managed to engage us in fighting against each other on them. And some of us do not want to have anything to do with people who disagree with us.

We often take a portion of the Bible, a statement or verse, and make a doctrine out of that. We neglect other passages that may contradict the passages that we choose to make our doctrines.

Denominations develop their fundamental doctrines using only a portion or some portions of the Bible, and neglecting others. They don’t consider that there are other words and statements that may seem to contradict those words and statements they rely on as the basis for their doctrinal beliefs.

My lecturer, Ms. Eunson, taught us in class, in my first year in Bible Seminary, that we must always carefully analyze the words and statements when they seem to contradict. If two words or statements seem to contradict, we must always search further to see if there are other words or statements that might contradict the ones we are reading. If there are other words and statements that seem to contradict the ones we are reading or that seem to be neutral, then we must ask why it is so. That introduces us to contextualization. Most of the words or statements were made in context.

Who are the true presenters of peace?

 Who are the true presenters of peace? Those who preach and conquer by violence? Or those who preach peace and love?
There are those who claim they are peaceful, yet they promote violence!
Christians were accused of embarking on the Crusades!

Islam and the Crusades Cover

The Christians explained that they were forced to embark on the Crusades in self-defense. They said they were pushed into a ‘life or death’ situation; there was nothing they could do to free themselves from the brutalities of the Jihad, so they had to fight back.

The Jihad

The Jihad started after 633 AD. Lands were conquered and the conquered people told they had to convert to the new religion. If they did not convert, they had to pay a protection levy so they could remain in their faith. However, they would not be allowed to proclaim openly their religious faith. Some could not pay the tax and so had to covert and accept the new religion imposed on them.

The warriors called their war(s) “The Jihad” — striving for God (which became popularized as Holy Wars); wars promoting God’s cause or religion.

Many died in the wars. Women and girls captured in the wars were forced to marry the conquerors and the sons of the conquerors. (The conquerors said they were doing the women a favor by marrying them as their husbands and men had died in the wars.)

Christians could not openly proclaim their faith anymore. Some churches were converted to accommodate the new faith and to serve as worship centers for the new faith. When the Christians could not bear the agony any longer, they cried to their leaders to do something about the situation. At first, the leaders would not respond.

Then the conquerors blocked the Mediterranean area, making trading activities difficult. When Pilgrimage to Jerusalem, the Christian Holy Land, was also made difficult to Christians, the Christian leaders decided to respond.

It took 400 years for the Christians to respond. (The first Crusade was in the 11th Century, while the Jihad started earlier in the 7th century.)
The Christians responded to free themselves and their lands from the invaders who had caused much pain and sorrow to many families.  The invaders cried out and condemned the action of the Christians. They said it was wrong for the Christians to rise up and fight (though the Christians were actually defending themselves).

The Christians, too, (actually) went into excesses

Although the Christians went into excesses, those who started the hostilities (the Jihad) 400 years earlier should also have been told that they were wrong in starting their holy war. But that did not happen; rather the Christians who decided to defend themselves were accused of embarking on the war (to defend themselves).

The Crusades (and the Jihad) finally ended.  Both Muslims and Christians learned that war was not right.

(You may want to read, “Conquering Without  Being Violent.”)

Now another form of Jihad has emerged!!!

Suicide bombings, horrific killings, (decapitation of Christians, journalists and others), abductions, rape, etc., are being used to promote a cause.
Those who commit the atrocities say they are a peaceful and loving people. They assert that they are preaching a peace-loving deity, and that they are only proclaiming to the world how good it is to follow their ‘peaceful’ cause. They use violence because they want everyone to love and worship their compassionate deity!!!

Is this the world God intended?

The Bible presents a God of peace who sent the Prince of Peace (Jesus Christ) to preach love, forgiveness, peace and non-violence.

(Get a copy of “Persuasion Is Better Than Force”)

Peace-lovers preach a peaceful God, not a violent and killer deity!

Peace-lovers do not preach hate!

You destroy the cause you represent when you preach and practice violence! You destroy the testimony of your fellow believers who are peace-lovers and who preach peace!

How Christianity wins without attacking

Winning without attacking people

WE CONQUER WITHOUT VIOLENCE
  • Violent, intolerant people become angry when they fail to convince people to accept their views.
  • Angry husbands brutalize their wives and children when they are unable to make them accept their views.
  • Religious militants attack people and force their religions on them.

Compelling people to accept your views will not make them love you

Jesus taught His followers to use peaceful persuasion.

Aesop illustrates  this in a fable, the North Wind and the Sun.

The North Wind and the Sun argued about who was stronger. They agreed to try their powers upon a traveler, to see who could strip him of his cloak. The North Wind, gathering up all his force, came whirling furiously down upon the man, and caught up his cloak to wrest it from him; but the harder he blew, the more closely the man wrapped it round himself. Failing, he called upon the Sun to see what he, too, could do.

At first, the Sun beamed gently and warmly upon the traveler. The traveler, feeling the genial rays of the sun took off his garment, and walked with it hanging loosely on his shoulders. The Sun continued gradually until he finally released his full strength. At last, the man, overcome with heat, undressed and bathed in a stream that lay in his path, before completing his journey, more lightly clad.

When the Wind tried to wrest the cloak from the traveler, he fought back; on the other hand, when the Sun suggested that it was uncomfortable for him to wear his cloak in that heat, the man accepted the suggestion.

Convincing the listener is  more effective in winning a person

Do not compel people to believe.  Jesus said,

“But whatever city you enter, and they do not receive you, go out into its streets and say, ‘The very dust of your city which clings to us we wipe off against you. Nevertheless know this that the kingdom of God has come near you.’ But I say to you that it will be more tolerable in that Day for Sodom than for that city.” (Luke 10:10-12)

Biblical Christianity is non-violent

God has tremendous power to control people’s minds to worship Him. Yet, He has chosen not to do so. Being a loving God, He does not send suicide bombers to kill innocent people.

Why do Islamic militants prefer using force to make others accept their views?

The Qur’an, in 29:6, says, “And whoever strives, he strives only for himself. Verily, Allah stands not in need of any of the ‘Alamin (mankind, jinn and all that exists)…” (The Noble Qur’an: English translation of the Meanings and Commentary.)

The Qur’an emphatically declares that, “There is no compulsion in religion,” (2:256)

Again we read,

“And had your Lord willed, those on earth would have believed, all of them together. So, will you (O Muhammad) then compel mankind, until they become believers? It is not for any person to believe, except by the leave of Allah, and he will put the wrath on those who are heedless.” (10:99-100)

Why then do Muslim militants compel people to worship Allah?

Suicide bombers attack and kill people because they believe that when they die in the attacks, they will gain paradise. The militants, therefore, do not commit the atrocities on God’s behalf.

  • Jesus used love and persuasion to win Zacchaeus, (Luke 19:1-10)
  • He used persuasion to make the Samaritan woman understand Him, (John 4:7-30)
  • He said, “Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you; bless those who curse you and pray for those who spitefully use you,” (Luke 6:27-28)

For further reading visit: http://www.peacemakersteam.com/books.html

Christianity wins without attacking
Christianity wins by love. Jesus taught us to win without attacking.

True and saving religion should have the power to appeal

Genuine religion should be able to persuade and draw people to itself. When we use force we rather emphasize the negative judgments people have formed of us.

Killing innocent people, and abducting defenseless girls and women in the name of God does not help promote God’s cause.

Burning villages and churches, and killing Christians and people who do not accept their religions rather make the victims to hate the attackers and their religions.

We present a wicked, hardhearted God when we are intolerant and violent.

Winning Without Attacking
Rockeybell speaking on “How to communicate with hostile people.”

The Christian God is non-violent

  • The Christian God loves
  • He is truly compassionate.
  • He does not terrorize people.

Share your views with us on winning without fighting, and how can we make the world peaceful.

Visit us at The Peacemakers Team